Foreign secretary David Cameron has confirmed that the UK will not follow the US and suspend any weapons sales to Israel despite its horrific ongoing bombardment of Rafah.
However, Campaign Against Arms Trade (CAAT) allege that Cameron’s comments were at best misleading, and at worst, downright lies.
David Cameron: lie after lie
New figures from CAAT estimate that the real value of arms exports to Israel is twice as high as the government claims it is – at least £1bn since 2015.
Cameron claimed that UK arms sales are not comparable with the US because “we do not have a UK government supply of weapons to Israel, we have a number of licences”.
While UK exports are much smaller than the US, whether they are transferred directly through the government, or whether the government issues licences is irrelevant to the UK’s obligations under International Humanitarian Law. The F-35 jets dropping bombs on Gaza for the last seven months would not be in the sky without the components made all across the UK.
He also said that UK licensing procedures are “some of the toughest in the world”.
The UK’s weak export rules for Israel
However, recent revelations in the legal case against the UK government over arms sales showed that there has been a “hiatus” in the legal assessments needed to assess whether Israel is breaching international humanitarian law (IHL), and that “decisions of some importance have been delayed for some time”.
The last assessment took place on 8 April. However, according to information given in court, this review only covered IHL violations committed in the period up to 28 January. Under UK export rules, arms sales must be halted when there is a clear risk they could be used to break international law.
Finally, Cameron claimed that “our defence exports to Israel are responsible for significantly less than 1% of their total”.
The value of arms sales: not what the government says
CAAT estimates that the real value of arms exports to Israel is twice as high as the government claims it is – at least £1bn since 2015. The UK has exported £489m in single issue licences since 2015. However, 62 open licences have also been issued since 2015. Under open licences, a company can export unlimited amounts of specified military equipment without further reporting requirements.
One open licence is for components for the F35 fighter jets Israel is using to bombard Gaza – 15% of the value of every F-35 is produced in the UK. CAAT estimates this licence has been worth at least £368m to UK industry since 2016.
However, this figure is just for the initial building of the planes. It doesn’t cover the spare parts that Israel will have needed in order to continue its bombardment. CAAT does not know the full value of the other licences. It also does not know if there has been an increase in arms exports following 7 October due to a lag in the data.
‘Morally bankrupt’
On 7 May CAAT issued a statement on the invasion of Rafah. It beings:
Our government and opposition leadership were given advance notice by Israel that they would commit these crimes against humanity, and their failure to call for a ceasefire, failure to stop arming this genocide, and failure to hold Israel to account is what has brought this horror to Gaza.
For months, UK Ministers have acted under the pretense that an unfathomable escalation from Israel in Rafah was needed for them to take meaningful action.
This response from our so-called leaders is morally bankrupt and unforgivable. It has allowed Israel to commit genocide with impunity, and created a hell on earth for the people of Gaza. Now that the invasion of Rafah is underway we see that this ‘red line’ is nothing more than rhetoric.
Cameron: ‘complicit in genocide’ and a ‘liar’
CAAT’s media coordinator Emily Apple said:
Not only is David Cameron complicit in genocide, he is lying to the country about UK arms exports. The UK’s licensing system is not robust. It is murky and unaccountable. Israel is using UK military equipment to commit utterly horrific war crimes in Gaza and this government is still refusing to act.
This government pretended Rafah was a red line. This was a sickening lie.
The atrocities Palestinian people are facing in Rafah are beyond words. But Cameron’s comments show that he intends to continue prioritising the profits of arms dealers, shamefully disregarding international law and treating Palestinian lives with unforgivable contempt. This has to stop and he must face the consequences for his utterly immoral actions.
Featured image via the Canary
