Crime and policing have been in the headlines this week. Figures showed a spike in violent crime in London, with 50 murders taking place so far in 2018.
The government has been quick to respond, bringing legislation to parliament which will tighten controls on weapons. Likewise, Labour has come out strongly in condemning cuts to police numbers, which it believes has contributed to the rise in violent crime.
The state acts to “stereotype, stigmatise and criminalise” young people
But in a powerful interview on Sky’s Sunday with Niall Paterson, Tottenham based activist Stafford Scott slammed state action from both government and the police. Throughout the interview, Scott argued that decisions taken by the state are behind the crime spike.
Scott said:
The state is using every single agency that it has… to stereotype, stigmatise and criminalise these young people.
He elsewhere argued that government policies have put further pressure on young people through this stigmatisation and stereotyping:
Today, this government is telling us that three youths can be a gang. I have two brothers. I come from a place called Tottenham. That means that these people today would define myself and my brothers as being members of a gang. Once you’re stereotyped as being a gang and stigmatised, you’re just pushed out onto the streets.
More police will cause more reaction
Scott’s criticism went further. He condemned claims that heavier policing will reduce violent crime. In two separate responses, he argued that higher police numbers, as Labour have been calling for, won’t solve the problem:
"Do you really think the kids are sitting at home this morning watching this programme to learn there's fewer police and then thinking as a result of that 'we are going to go out there and do something'?" #Paterson #knifecrime pic.twitter.com/6EOePk33Zu
— Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge (@SkyPoliticsHub) April 8, 2018
"They didn't call skinhead violence white-on-white crime"… so why are they calling this "black-on-black crime"? – community activist says racism and labelling is playing a role in toughness of police measures #Paterson pic.twitter.com/0yP8F3UlRW
— Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge (@SkyPoliticsHub) April 8, 2018
Myth busting and more
After the interview, Scott then took to Twitter, taking on those who responded to his comments and breaking down common misconceptions about violent crime.
First, he tackled the myth that violent crime is a product of single-parent households:
It is most definitely NOT an issue that effects single parent households. I have met with young people who live with both parents yet are at the ‘cutting’ edge of this madness. To address the issues we must unite not divide the community 🙏🏾 https://t.co/KQuBQm2dpS
— Stafford Scott (@StaffordScott_) April 8, 2018
To a degree my brother, but I have been out there and this is not simply about the absence of black fathers. When such crimes were happening on a greater scale in Glasgow it was t that absence of black fathers that caused that. It’s about CHILDREN being kicked on the scrap heap https://t.co/EDw4TFGw2I
— Stafford Scott (@StaffordScott_) April 8, 2018
Then he went on to lay into Government cuts to services:
Cutting funding to society’s most vulnerable in the name of austerity, whilst the bankers are still swilling at the pen, is a corrupt practice that central, regional and local Government should be ashamed of but ultimately held accountable for 🙏🏾 https://t.co/LALItc0ods
— Stafford Scott (@StaffordScott_) April 8, 2018
And he also reserved some criticism for the way the mainstream media has hosted the debate:
My brother this is why we are in this predicament in the 1st place. Make no doubt about it we ARE treated as a SUSPECT community by the authorities, thats why they do not invite us to sit around the table, as they do not understand COMMUNITY & therefore see us as part of the gang https://t.co/WXXOAtvH5v
— Stafford Scott (@StaffordScott_) April 8, 2018
A refreshing voice
The public debate on violent crime has become stale, focusing on knee-jerk reactions and short term, short sighted ‘solutions’. Perhaps we’d get closer to tackling the underlying problems if voices like Stafford Scott’s were heard more often.
Get Involved!
– Join The Canary, so we can keep holding the powerful to account.
– Read and support other independent media outlets:
Media Diversified, Novara Media, Corporate Watch, Red Pepper, New Internationalist, Common Space, Media Lens, Bella Caledonia, Vox Political, Evolve Politics, Real Media, Reel News, STRIKE! magazine, The Bristol Cable, The Meteor, The Skwawkbox, Salford Star, The Ferret.
Featured image via Twitter Screengrab.
